Labour of Love

I had the opportunity earlier this year of observing Luthier and master craftsman, James Beatley, at work.

Below are some of the images I took (click on them for the bigger versions) and some questions that James was also kind enough to answer for me to give us a better insight into the process that sees him produce such exceptional instruments at his workshop in his home in Stoneybatter.

What drove you to make your first instrument?

When I was in  my early 20s, I  was playing the tenor banjo. I  had heard about the short scale banjo, which would be better suited to my style of playing. Back then (pre Internet) it was very difficult to find one in Ireland. After a few years searching with no luck I decided to make one. This was a journey which took me three years to complete – the main problem was sourcing  materials. Now it is so easy just Google.

What finally inspired you to make the jump from mechanical engineering to become a full-time Luthier?

There are lots of reasons. Having been making instruments for about 15 years as a hobby I desired to take the making to a higher level. I  wanted to learn more about restoration of instruments too. My job with the ESB  had  undergone a massive restructuring, which would have left me at the same level  until retirement. It was time to go.

How would you describe your working process when making an instrument?

Almost all the instruments I make are after classical Italian makers from Anno 1700.  I  make the instruments  in the same method and use the same tools as were used then. Nothing really has changed except sometimes I would use some modern tools, both mechanical and electronic, to make more exact measurements.  For example, when making a front or back of a violin you would be most concerned with the stiffness of the finished piece, both across the grain and with the grain. I  like to think of this as a stiffness rather than a flexibility. Whatever stiffness you decide on will be  the biggest contributor to the overall sonority of the instruments. Normally this stiffness is felt in the hands by twisting and pressing on the wood and listening to the tap tones. You can guess a tap tone very easily to within a semitone. For example if  I  want the wood to ring at F# I can  be fairly accurate, but the difference could be as much as 15hz from one to another. By using a sine wave generator you can be exact in matching your front and back. Carleen Hutchings (1911-2009) was an American violin maker and pioneer in plate tuning. In the 1950s she  wrote a scientific paper on violin plate tuning using Eiginmodes and Chladni patterns.

What parts of the process you enjoy the most?

It might be easier to answer what parts I least enjoy. This would be the initial preparation of the  wood – flattening  and preparing the centre joints for glueing and squaring up the neck block. After this initial work is done it is a slow labour of love. On completion the setting up and playing of the instrument for the first time is very satisfying.

What are the most challenging aspects?

I think any Luthier will agree with me that varnishing is the most challenging and difficult part of the whole process to master. The problems here are their is only one  good supplier of ready-made varnish for the violin family of instruments and this maker’s varnish does not meet all of the desired qualities. So most makers who know what is required will try to make their own. Personally, I  have experimented with recipes for about 16 years. The varnish  I’m using now and for the last four years is working really well for me.

What is it about the violin that makes it such a special instrument?

I  think because it is  so close to the human voice makes it universally used in all genres of music. Anyone who has tried to learn the violin will tell you it is very demanding and difficult to learn. The fun of learning is in the challenge and you can take it to what ever level you desire. From a physics point of view their are many scientific papers written about how the violin works, they are all probably a little bit right and many disagree and contradict each other , ut one thing is for sure – the violin is a very inefficient  instrument as most of the energy put into the playing is lost in damping etc  90% of what you hear can be directly  attributed to the musician and the rest to the instrument.

Does making instruments give you a different perspective when playing them?

Not really, being a  maker or not  one can appreciate a good instrument. If  I  pick up an instrument which does not work so well or is set up badly  I  won’t want to play it. The same goes for anyone.

Is each instrument unique and, if so, how?

Yes, no two instruments are the same.  Each will have it own voice and  aesthetic values. Making two violins of the same model when finished there are many anomalies between both. No two pieces of wood are the same or have the same acoustic attributes. Every single part of the instrument has an acoustical contribution. The scroll size and design. The density of the fingerboard will have an acoustic resonance which will effect the body mode, which should match the air mode. The overall set up – type of pegs used the bridge blank, tailpiece etc every part has its own acoustic value.  This is why we make to tap tones and not measurements.

Do you feel you are still learning all the time?

Yes  sometimes even doing a job you have done many times before their is a ‘light bulb’ moment. Recently there has been the publication of a book, Restoration and Conservation of Stringed Instruments. This is a collaboration of all the best makers and restorers from around the world.  It’s a massive volume. Since  I  bought it every time I undertake a repair I consult the book to see how other makers approach a particular task.  Often I will adapt my method with ideas from this book.

Whose work are you most influenced or inspired by?

Giussepe Guarneri del Gesú is my favourite maker. There is a beautiful freeness of the use of his tools, evident by the tool marks in his work. These marks also contribute to the aesthetic beauty of his instruments. The purfling of his instruments is poorly executed, but all these little aspects add to the overall aesthetic beauty. His ideas on design for acoustic value were revolutionary at the time. My preference in making is to make my instruments have an aesthetic desirability as well as being of good sonority. The challenge in making an instrument look new and precise is a bit boring for me.

Do you strive for perfection?

You might ask ‘what is perfection?’ If  I am making a copy of a classical Italian instrument I will have to do every repair which has been done to a violin which could be over 300-years-old.  I  will do all these repairs with the greatest of care so yes I strive for perfection. On the other hand. I  may be asked to make a violin as new, but  I must admit to have softened the corners and the eyes of the scroll and rounding off the inside  top of the peg box to give some character to the instrument otherwise I feel the instrument looks boring… am I striving for perfection?!

Do you feel your instruments will form a large part of your legacy? And do you ever think about that?

I do believe I am making good instruments, so good instruments usually fall into the hand of good musicians who look  after them well. My instruments could be around for several hundred years and just like Thomas Perry( 1744-1818), a Dublin maker,  I also brand-stamp my instruments. This stamp will always be there and will be a point of topic. On the other hand, I  had a life-changing moment recently when my computer hard drive gave up without warning. I  lost 18 years of collected data on all the instruments I have made. This would be an archive for future makers or anyone interested. My computer was just out of warranty and  I  had  a back-up hard drive for about six weeks, which I had not used.  Also all my  images of customer repairs and all of my  business advertising, accounts etc were gone. My initial reaction was ‘Fu… k’ , but then  I thought if I had suddenly died in the morning ‘so what’. Would it matter about my life’s long work? I  guess it only matters to me.

Posted on October 2, 2012, in Art, Dublin, Ireland, Music, Photography and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 69 Comments.

  1. Stunning pictures and stunning craft… The black and white photos add so much atmosphere to them, almost like it’s really going back in time!

  2. A very interesting post. So sad the fella lost so much data when the drive gave out. So good to see people with such passion for their work, this man creates works of art with his passion.

  3. Wow, having learnt violin as a child, this post brings such a different perspective to the instrument. The photos evoke the strong emotional process that each craftsman would pass on to the instrument as they perfect each curve and stroke.

    And yes, violin is an incredibly hard instrument to learn. But it’s so worth it!

  4. I enjoyed reading your interview with a violin maker. The images are great. They remind me of the Appalachian dulcimer I made a long time ago. Unfortunately, mine was not perfect and I never learned to play it.

  5. Very interesting read…..and some great images

  6. What a fascinating article. I rarely give any thought to all the work involved in creating fine instruments. It must be quite an accomplishment to truly create such art. It must then be so exciting to hear ne’s own creation produce music. Thanks

    • Having only got a glimpse into the process, I was amazed by how labour and time intensive it is to create top quality violins and cellos. Most defionitely a labour of love, you couldn’t possibly do it otherwise.

  7. Excellent post – good to see there are still people like this around and people like you to document their love of their craft.

  8. You can’t ever go wrong with Black and White Photography

  9. exiledprospero

    A true craftsman and philosopher – and i’m sure that this is exactly what Niccolò Paganini would have wanted in a violin maker.

  10. Terrific series Conor and excellent use of B&W!

  11. Amazing. I agree with Phil on the use of b&w, great choice.

    Have you ever taken a darkroom photography course? You might like it; that is my favorite photography.

  12. Northern Narratives

    I very much enjoyed this post.

  13. Really nice, Conor…I do personal documentaries probably for the same reason you did this piece on James. There are stories that shape all of our lives and they are worthy of being told. Thanks to you and James for sharing!

  14. Outstanding!! You captured the essence of where music begins! The genesis of sound. Thank you!!!

  15. Such an awesome post! Loving the documentation!

  16. Excellent post – great read and lovely shots to accompany it 🙂

  17. itisalonelyworld

    These are lovely photos! (:

  18. As a cellist myself, I really like this post, beautiful photography!

  19. I’m always in awe of such gifted and talented people. Thanks for sharing and your photos captured the story beautifully!

  20. Your posts and photos are always so interesting. You set the standard.

  21. Great interview… now i knw what goes into to make an instruments and great knowing Mr. James Beatley!

  22. I felt like I was watching a documentary film. Nice interview and images!

  23. Nice story and photos.
    FYI – you need to fix the link in the first paragraph.

  24. Enjoyed the post very much, loved the combination of photos and interview – both quite thoughtful. Also, I read the paragraph “About Connor Cullen” for the first time. Not sure I can imagine the jumper you describe in any manner other than ironically, but then most of my brain power is suddenly being taken up in memories of the lovely sandwiches of my past…

  25. This is a great little project! Fascinating subject matter beautifully handled. Inspired to finally pursue a project that i’ve been sitting on for a while. Thanks

  26. This absolutely fantastic, both the interview and, especially, the photography to it. Thank you for sharing it.

  27. I wish I could “like” this more than once. Love this story.

  28. Great post. I grew up playing wood wind instruments and never really thought about the efficiency of an instrument. And the black and white photos set an amazing tone for the interview.

    • Thanks Johny. Do you still play?

      • I haven’t played in ages. I’m not sure if I can still can play or read music but I’m sure that it’s like riding a bike. I actually handed down my alto sax to my nephew who picked it up quick. I’ve been eyeing guitars, maybe when I have more time I’ll learn to play one.

      • Ya, I’d love to have a go at the piano again after a few years playing it in my youth, but time is my main obstacle as well.

  29. When I initially commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each
    time a comment is added I get three e-mails with the same comment.
    Is there any way you can remove people from that service?
    Thanks a lot!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: